Passing Children Through Fire: Sacrifice, Burial, and a New Reading of Judah’s Polemic

In an Iron Age Judahite rock-cut tomb, death did not necessarily separate a child from the household. Bodies were laid within family burial spaces; later, bones and personal objects could be gathered into repository pits with the remains of earlier generations. Along parts of the Levantine coast, some communities followed a visibly different path: cremation, often placing the burned remains in urns.
Those contrasting landscapes of death now stand behind a new reading of one of the Hebrew Bible’s most disturbing phrases: making a son or daughter “pass through fire.” Kristine Henriksen Garroway argues in the Journal of Biblical Literature that the texts work on two levels. Their explicit attack is directed at child sacrifice. Beneath it, she proposes, lies a second polemic that treats foreign-style cremation burial as an assault on Judahite identity.

The Hinnom Valley in Jerusalem, the geographical setting of the biblical Topheth passages; this view does not identify an excavated sacrificial installation. Photo: Joe Freeman, CC BY-SA 2.5. Source · License
How This Connects To The Bible
The connection to Scripture is direct: these are the passages the new interpretation seeks to explain. Leviticus 18:21 forbids giving descendants to Molech, while Deuteronomy 18:10 prohibits making a son or daughter pass through fire. Second Kings 23:10 describes Josiah defiling Topheth in the Valley of Ben Hinnom to prevent that practice.
Jeremiah 7:31 and 19:5 speak explicitly of sons and daughters being burned, with Jeremiah 19:5 identifying them as burnt offerings to Baal. In these passages, the biblical condemnation concerns worship God rejects and the destruction of children. Garroway’s proposal explores whether the language also attacks foreign cremation and burial customs; that additional interpretation remains a scholarly argument rather than an established archaeological finding.
Burial archaeology helps readers understand the family, religious, and social setting of these texts. It does not establish what happened to every child or prove that the biblical descriptions refer only to funerals. The distinction matters: a proposal about an additional layer of meaning should not obscure what the passages explicitly say.
What The New Article Proposes
The article, published in Journal of Biblical Literature 145.3 in September 2026 and highlighted by Hebrew Union College on October 27, begins with a long-running debate. Biblical passages in Leviticus, Deuteronomy, Kings and Jeremiah condemn giving children to Molek, burning sons and daughters, or passing them through fire. Many scholars have understood that language as evidence for child sacrifice.
Garroway does not simply erase that reading. Her formulation keeps an explicit polemic against sacrifice while adding a hidden one. She asks whether fire could also function as coded language for cremation—the burial practice biblical writers associated with outsiders, failed burial and the disintegration of the Judahite household in death.
What is genuinely new: the article places the biblical fire texts in direct conversation with recent archaeology of children’s burials. It shifts the question from only “Was a child killed?” to “What kind of death and burial did a Judahite writer mark as foreign, dangerous or identity-breaking?”
Two Mortuary Worlds
The archaeological contrast is central to the argument. In Iron Age Judah, children and adults could be incorporated into family bench tombs. Repository pits mixed generations together, sustaining the household as a collective beyond death. Garroway interprets that inclusion as evidence that even infants and young children possessed a place within Judahite family identity.
Cremation was relatively uncommon inland but occurred more often along Phoenician-influenced parts of the Levantine coast. Archaeologists have documented cremated children at several sites, although the famous mass infant-cremation precincts known from Carthage are not securely attested in the Phoenician homeland or ancient Israel. The absence of a Carthage-style tophet in Judah matters, but it cannot prove that no sacrificial act ever occurred.
The contrast is therefore not a simple map of good people and bad people. Coastal and inland communities practiced varied rites, and cremation could carry different meanings in different places. Garroway’s proposal concerns the rhetoric of biblical writers: they could take a recognizable foreign mortuary practice and turn it into a symbol of everything a Judahite family should reject.

A reconstructed seventh–sixth-century BCE Ketef Hinnom burial cave at the Israel Museum. This illustrates Judahite burial practice, not evidence of child sacrifice. Photo: Chamberi, CC BY-SA 3.0. Source · License
The Valley Behind The Text
Several biblical condemnations place the practice at Topheth in the Valley of Ben Hinnom, south of ancient Jerusalem. Second Kings 23 presents King Josiah defiling the site so that no one could make a child pass through fire to Molek. Jeremiah 7:31 and 19:5 describe high places where sons and daughters were burned.
This is the same larger Jerusalem valley system that gives Ketef Hinnom its modern archaeological name, but the new JBL article is not a new study of the silver amulets. The connection is geographical and textual: a valley beside Jerusalem became a charged stage for arguments about worship, death and communal boundaries.
Why The Sacrifice Debate Remains Open
The language of fire is difficult because literary polemic is not an excavation report. A writer may describe a real ritual, exaggerate an opponent’s practice, collapse several practices together, or use one act as a metaphor for another. Archaeology can identify urns, burned bone, age profiles and burial settings; it cannot always reveal whether death preceded cremation, whether a killing was sacrificial, or how every participant understood the rite.
Phoenician and Punic tophets show the problem clearly. Some scholars see urns containing cremated infants and animals as evidence of sacrifice. Others interpret at least part of the material as special cemeteries for children who died naturally. Recent bioarchaeology has documented deliberate postmortem care without establishing sacrifice in the individuals examined. The field does not have one universally accepted explanation for every tophet.
Garroway’s hidden-polemic reading should therefore be presented as a new scholarly proposal, not a replacement consensus. Its strength is that it explains why burial practice, ethnicity and household continuity may sit beneath the biblical language. Its uncertainty is the same evidence gap that drives the wider debate: texts condemn; bones and urns survive; the exact ritual joining them is often unrecoverable.
Identity At The Edge Of Exile
The proposal becomes especially powerful in the late monarchic and exilic world. Judah faced imperial pressure, population displacement and the threat that families would be scattered beyond their ancestral land and tombs. In that setting, burial was not merely disposal of a body. It was a claim about belonging—to a household, a place and a people.
A polemic against cremation could therefore carry political force without being a government policy in the modern sense. Biblical authors and reforming elites defined proper worship and proper death while labeling rival practices foreign. The surviving texts preserve the winners’ rhetoric, not a neutral account from every community being condemned.
How Headlines Can Overstate The Evidence
A sensational version of this story would say that archaeology has disproved child sacrifice in ancient Judah. The article does not warrant that conclusion. Nor does the lack of a local tophet demonstrate that the biblical accusations were invented.
A responsible headline is narrower: new mortuary research allows the fire passages to be read on more than one rhetorical level. Child sacrifice remains the explicit horror in the text, while cremation and foreign burial may form a second, coded target.
Between Tomb And Text
From a Judahite family tomb to a coastal urn burial, the surviving evidence brings the human questions into focus: how were children remembered, and what did belonging to a household mean after death? Returning to the biblical passages with those settings in mind makes the debate more concrete while leaving its uncertainties visible.
The debate concerns more than a technical Hebrew phrase. It asks how ancient communities treated children after death, how families expressed belonging, and how these practices may illuminate the Bible’s condemnations of forbidden worship.

Ketef Hinnom provides geographical and burial context for ancient Jerusalem. The silver amulets found here are a separate discovery from the study discussed in this article. Photo: McKaby, CC BY-SA 4.0. Source · License
Additional Scholarly Context
The BAS treatment Infants Sacrificed? The Tale Teeth Tell opens with the biblical accusations in Jeremiah, Leviticus, and Chronicles, then distinguishes those texts from archaeological evidence in the Hinnom Valley. That is a useful safeguard for this discussion: a passage describing a practice and excavated remains demonstrating a specific event are different forms of evidence. The BAS article’s bibliography also points readers toward opposing interpretations of Carthaginian child burials. Those Mediterranean comparisons frame a debate; they cannot automatically establish what happened at Topheth in Judah.
The Scientific Disagreement Behind The Headlines
Patricia Smith’s full BAS article argues for sacrifice at Carthage using infant age profiles. Her team corrected estimates for heat-related shrinkage of teeth; she contends that failing to make that correction makes some infants appear younger and changes the interpretation of the cemetery. Other researchers disputed the conclusions. This is a concrete example of how analytical choices affect the sacrifice debate. Carthage’s evidence remains geographically and culturally distinct from Judah, so it cannot establish what happened in Jerusalem’s Hinnom Valley.
One Text Can Carry Two Polemics
Kristine Henriksen Garroway’s proposal does not simply replace sacrifice with cremation. She argues that the biblical language can operate on two rhetorical levels at once: an explicit accusation against child sacrifice and a hidden argument about burial identity. Cremated children could be portrayed as receiving a foreign or “bad” burial outside the Judahite household ideal. This remains an interpretive proposal, not archaeological proof that every fire passage describes cremation—or that child sacrifice never occurred.
Sources And Further Reading
Worth reading in full: Kristine Henriksen Garroway, “Buried Identities: The (Hidden) Polemic against Passing a Child through Fire” — Journal of Biblical Literature 145.3 (2026), pp. 399–420. Peer-reviewed. The full text requires journal or SBL access.
Hebrew Union College research summary — Concise institutional summary of the article’s two-level argument, posted October 27, 2026.
Garroway, The Dying Child: The Death and Personhood of Children in Ancient Israel — The broader archaeological and social-history foundation for the argument, including regional burial comparisons and the place of children in Judahite family tombs.
“The Tophet and Infant Sacrifice,” Oxford Handbook of the Phoenician and Punic Mediterranean — A useful orientation to the major archaeological and interpretive disputes; worth consulting before presenting any single explanation as settled.
“The life and death of cremated infants and children from the Neo-Punic tophet at Zita, Tunisia” — Peer-reviewed bioarchaeological study illustrating why careful treatment after death does not by itself settle whether sacrifice occurred.
Biblical references: Leviticus 18:21; Deuteronomy 18:10; 2 Kings 23:10; Jeremiah 7:31; Jeremiah 19:5 (see the NKJV).




Comments