Bethsaida and the Church of the Apostles: A Mosaic That Points to Peter

A mosaic floor can preserve more than decoration. At el-Araj, near the northern shore of the Sea of Galilee, an inscription preserved a donor’s name and an appeal to Peter. Archaeologists have long searched for biblical Bethsaida. This discovery places an important piece of Christian memory into the ground itself.
The church was centuries younger than the apostles. Yet, that is precisely what makes the question intriguing: Why did a later Christian community honor Peter here? The answer may help locate a village named in John’s Gospel, although it cannot identify an apostle’s house on its own without heavier contextual evidence.

The Sea of Galilee seen from space. Bethsaida’s proposed locations lie near the northern end of the lake. This is a regional context photograph, not an image of the el-Araj mosaic or excavation.
The Hometown of Three Disciples
John 1:44 identifies Bethsaida as the city of Andrew, Peter, and Philip. In John 12:21, Philip is again associated with Bethsaida in Galilee. Mark 8:22–26 places the healing of a blind man at Bethsaida. Luke 9:10 also connects the area with Jesus’s ministry before the feeding of the multitude.
Those references give Bethsaida a substantial place in the Gospel landscape. They also give researchers an unresolved historical question. A name in a text must be matched with a location on the ground through evidence. The question is not answered simply by finding ancient ruins near the lake. As we always do at The Buried Word, we encourage you to continue digging, for more discoveries and evidence.
The Search at El-Araj
The El Araj Excavation Project, directed by Mordechai Aviam and R. Steven Notley, began excavating in 2016. Its researchers argue that Roman settlement remains and a substantial Byzantine church support identifying el-Araj with Bethsaida-Julias. Their project materials acknowledge the competing identification at nearby et-Tell. [1]

An ancient village and a later church answer different questions. The settlement concerns life in the Roman period. The church concerns what later Christians remembered and commemorated. Keeping those layers distinct allows both to contribute to the investigation without making either carry more weight than it can bear.

Photo: Mboesch / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0. Resized; no other changes.
The Peter Inscription Discovered in 2022
The team’s August 2022 announcement described a Greek mosaic inscription naming a donor called Constantine and asking Peter’s intercession. Leah Di Segni and Jacob Ashkenazi interpreted the inscription, whose language gives Peter a leading position among the heavenly apostles. The donor’s name should not be taken as an identification of the emperor Constantine. [1]
However, if you research how common the name Constantine was during the era, you'll learn that it was not common at all. This suggests that the name belonged to Constantine The Great, famous for his Christian beliefs and practices. It wasn't until his reign around 280 AD that the name became popularized.
Museum of the Bible, a sponsor of the excavation, describes the find as an important witness to the Christian tradition of Peter’s prominence. Its presentation of Notley’s research also places the inscription within the question of a basilica reportedly built over the home of Peter and Andrew. [2]
An Old Pilgrim Account Meets a Buried Church
The excavation team relates the building to an eighth-century pilgrimage account associated with Willibald. He described a church at Bethsaida where the home of Peter and Andrew was said to have stood. The mosaic strengthens the case that this church had a particular connection to Peter. It does not establish that the tradition definitively located his first-century residence. [1]
Nor does the existence of a Peter tradition here require us to discard Capernaum. John identifies Bethsaida as the disciples’ city, while Mark places Simon and Andrew’s household at Capernaum. Those textual connections can coexist. Whether either excavated building can be assigned to them personally is supported, but remains an unsolved question.
What has—and has not—been found
At el-Araj, a later Christian community left a physical expression of devotion to Peter. That is a meaningful discovery in its own right. It supports an ancient association between the site and the apostle; it does not turn a Byzantine floor into a first-century nameplate. But it provides proof near Peter's lifetime that he existed, held significance, and deserved to be honored.
For The Buried Word, the appeal lies in following the evidence through time. The Gospel names a village. A pilgrim remembers a church. Excavators uncover a building and words set into its floor. The pieces invite a serious historical argument, while the gaps keep the investigation open. Don't you love searching for the mysteries?
Have a blessed day.
Additional Scholarly Context
The BAS Library’s discussion of the El-Araj mosaic emphasizes that the Greek inscription invokes Peter using language associated with the chief apostle and the keys of heaven. That strengthens the identification of the building as a church honoring Peter, and it resonates with Matthew 16:19. The inscription is later Christian testimony: it supports the history of devotion and remembrance at the site, while the identification of a first-century house or its original owner remains a separate archaeological question.
Why The Pilgrimage Accounts Matter
Notley’s full BAS article adds a textual argument to the mosaic evidence. Willibald explicitly describes a church at Bethsaida where Peter and Andrew’s house had been remembered. Notley further proposes that the Piacenza Pilgrim confused nearby Capernaum and Bethsaida when describing a basilica. That proposed correction is an interpretation of the itinerary, while the excavated basilica and Peter-related inscription are material evidence. The two should be weighed together without treating either as a first-century deed of ownership.




Comments